The Pittsburgh Steelers have an interesting history with the Philadelphia Eagles, but a terrible record against them. Both teams joined the NFL in the same year as they took advantage of the repeal of the Blue Laws that inhibited certain recreational activities on Sundays. Pro football was usually played on that day while Saturdays were reserved for college games.
Both the Steelers and Eagles struggled on and off the field in their early days. Art Rooney even brought a half share in the Eagles after selling his Steelers, only to swap cities when he moved the Eagles back to Pittsburgh retaining their Steelers name.
When the second World War broke out and football lost players to the services, the two teams merged for a season to share their resources. Art Rooney would give the Eagles their first winning season in 1943 as one half of the Steagles.
The Eagles have an overall series lead of 50-28-3. In Philadelphia they have a 29-8-2 advantage and ominously have a current winning streak of eleven. It was 1965 when the Steelers last left Philadelphia feeling their brotherly love with a win.
The Steelers finished the 1962 season with a 9-5 record, as John Henry Johnson contributed 1141 yards rushing with 7 touchdowns. Finishing second in the East Division behind the New York Giants, saw them play the Lions in the Playoff Bowl which they lost 10-17.
The following season would see the Steelers coached by Buddy Parker for the seventh year. The Eagles were coached by Nick Skorich, who played three seasons with the Steelers.
Controversy struck before the game with a story circulating that the Steelers had scouted the Eagles practice during the week. Parker joked, “If anybody took those notes, I wish they’d bring them around to me.” Skorich also noted that the Eagles were the only team which didn’t have facilities for private practice.
Adding some realism to the dispute, Parker said he was more worried about the Eagles receivers. “With Jurgensen (quarterback) and those receivers, you don’t bother much with secret plays.”
After his retirement, the Steelers would be without Bobby Layne for the first time in five years. Veteran Ed Brown who had been a bench warmer for three seasons was his replacement.
The (0-0) Steelers at the (0-0) Eagles; September 15, 1963
Buddy Parker’s concerns regarding Sonny Jurgensen were fully justified on the Eagles first drive. Jurgensen took them 74 yards on 9 plays before tossing a 13-yard touchdown pass to Tommy McDonald.
Unknown to the 58,000 fans watching the game in Franklin Field, Steelers John Reger came close to death on the last play of the first quarter. Reger was knocked unconscious when tackling a Philadelphia fullback and swallowed his tongue. The swift action of the Eagles and Steelers medical staff remedied a serious situation before an ambulance took him to hospital.
With both teams in a defensive struggle, the Steelers didn’t reply until the second quarter. The usually Mr. Reliable Lou Michaels kicked field goals from 38 and 50 yards. He also missed another with just seconds left in the half from 50 yards in a hurry up situation. The Steelers went into the locker room behind 6-7.
The Eagles struck again in the third quarter after a fumble by John Henry Johnson. Jurgensen hit a pass of 42 yards to Timmy Brown giving Philadelphia a first down on the Steelers 6 to the wild enthusiasm of the home fans. Jurgensen’s 6-yard touchdown pass to Catfish Smith ensured the fans increased the volume as the Eagles now led 14-6.
After another Michael’s field goal attempt from 37 yards went wide left, the game went into the final quarter. Michaels then succeeded with a 17-yard field goal attempt.
The Steelers defense forced the Eagle to punt on their next possession. The kick went 62 yards before it was muffed by Keys Brady. He recovered the ball and wheeled to the right sideline where he raced 71 yards before slipping at the Eagles 3. Two plays later Johnson carried it over from 3 yards to ensure the Pittsburgh score. Michaels’ point after attempt was blocked, but the Steelers were ahead for the first time by one point.
Another outstanding Eagles play saw Tommy McDonald race past the Steelers defensive line before completing an over the shoulder catch for a 74-yard touchdown.
Michaels failed again on a 51-yard field goal attempt, but the Steelers kept pressing. Ed Brown found Johnson with a short pass over the middle. Johnson evaded the defense to score an 11-yard touchdown. Michaels missed the extra point that would have sealed a Pittsburgh Victory and the game ended in a tie.
The Pittsburgh Steelers 21 at the Philadelphia Eagles 21.
Lou Michael’s 50-yard field goal set a team record. On his performance with two missed field goals and two extra points, Michaels said, “It wasn’t my day. I always knew there was going to be a day like this, a nightmare. I didn’t know that it would happen in front of my hometown friends though.”
“That’s the first time I’ve seen two extra points missed,” lamented Buddy Parker.
The Steelers would have two more tied games during the season. A 17-17 tie against the Bears before a 20-20 tie when they hosted the Eagles.
They would finish the season 7-4-3 to put them in fourth place in the East division. The Eagles were the cellar dwellers at 2-10-2.
John Reger would recover from the scare that put him in hospital and returned to playing a month later. He was waived before the start of the 1964 season and played another three seasons with Washington.




